Wednesday, November 26, 2008

thoughts on gay marriage, part 1

As promised, some of my thoughts about gay marriage. If you haven't read my previous post wherein I share my thoughts about homosexuality in general, please do. First, some thoughts on definitions and the secular...

Recent debates in the US have centered around the "definition" of marriage. There is a federal "Defense of Marriage" law. The recent passage of Proposition 8 in California has brought the issue to the forefront again... and again, it's an issue of "defining" the term marriage.

The issue always sounds like a semantic one. Is "marriage" a commitment between any couple, or only a heterosexual couple? Certainly the semantics are important. The word "marriage" has a tremendous amount of baggage attached to it. When we hear the word, we think of the relationship between our parents. We think of a ceremony with a bride and groom. We think of special intimacy. We think of life together, through good times and bad. We think of tax implications (well, some people do). We think of marriage in the way it has been modeled around us, and that is different for everyone.

So I'd like to propose that we pause for a moment and consider not the definition of marriage, but the implications of marriage. (The effectual semantics.) In today's culture, any two people can have a relationship that mimics traditional marriage. Life together does not require a marriage certificate. Sex certainly doesn't. And all kinds of people raise children together (or apart). Call it what you will, in terms of practical lifestyle, marriage-like relationships are all over the place.

So why does it matter how marriage is defined?

A major issue is that marriage has significant financial repercussions. Married people (may) have different tax burdens than single people. And while any people can live together and share the burden of living expenses, health care is extremely expensive. It is an employer's insurance plan that dictates whether or not "domestic partners" -- people living together -- can be insured under each other's health insurance policy. (Interestingly, the policies vary by employer, not by health care company. Also, no one seems to be asking about relationships between more than two people. Yet.)

So from one perspective, the way the government and businesses define marriage is important because of these financial issues. Personally, this is where I think it is very easy to draw a sacred/secular line. When we're talking about taxes and health care costs, we're talking about secular stuff, not sacred stuff. This is where equal rights comes into play. While there's no equal rights amendment in the US Constitution, establishing justice is the second purpose statement of the constitution. Given this mission statement, I think that one couple should be treated the same as any other couple. Remember, their lifestyles are virtually indistinguishable from those of "married" couples. So I think that tax burdens and insurance requirements should be the same for any kind of couple, if there must be a distinction between couples and single people. (And there are good reasons to make that distinction. Ask me about it if you disagree.)

Of course, marriage has typically been the standard for deciding at what point a relationship is "official" enough to be recognized by businesses and the government. Without some kind of standard, any two people could decide to claim the official benefits/liabilities of couple-ness. So far, the idea of "civil union" has been the standard for distinguishing between random couples and "official" couples. It basically establishes the rights of kinship without a shared bloodline, just like marriage does otherwise. (A quick search shows that in NJ a civil union has age and same-gender requirements, as well as an "only-one-at-a-time" kind of rule). Wikipedia calls it a theoretical legal mechanism, and I think that's really all it is. A secular mechanism for determining legal status of couples. A mechanism for ensuring secular justice.

So far I've dealt with some of the secular issues. For many gay couples, the thing they care about is not so much legal rights as social and ideological acceptance. More on that next.

No comments: