Please read this in context.
The conundrum of faith and morals and justice and politics gets confusing. But even more confusing is the dilemma of Christian hope in a world where homosexuality is akin to normalcy.
It's like with my mom. She's been with her partner longer than she was married to my dad. I love her dearly, I want her life to be amazing. Most of all, I want her to know the riches and joy and satisfaction and overwhelming love of Jesus, to have the freedom of being who she was made to be. But I believe that when she gets to that point, as she begins to love God back, He'll ask her to give up the woman she's loved for more than fourteen years. Heartbreak. The trappings of divorce without the social sympathy. Hurting tons of people deeply, having them not understand. It scares the crap out of me, and I won't be the one having to do it. I definitely believe that following God is worth any sacrifice, but I shudder at the brokenness that will be so hard to recover from. So even though I pray for my mom to know the incredible love of God, I know I'm praying for her to experience horrible things, too. There will be healing and wholeness on the other side. It will be amazing. But it will take a long time, and it will be the hardest thing she ever does.
So look. I don't have all the answers. I only have a God I trust implicitly, a God who's revealed himself to me in a million ways and given me a book that reveals his character and truth even more. It's a dilemma: a righteous God and redeemed lawbreakers living in a world where truth, love, and goodness are scorned, mocked, and twisted. Until Christ is ruling and there's a perfect theocracy, politics and democracy will fail us. Ultimately my interest is not in what is legal or illegal, or moral or immoral. My interest is in helping people learn about how much they are loved, and how they were meant for something incredible, and how they have the opportunity to be free to be the person God made them to be. No matter how broken and dark and mucky life is, no matter how hurt an confused a person is, God has a way out for them. He did for me. He died for me. And if that doesn't make sense to you, ask me about it.
I may have one more post about this, in response to the article Dan posted about last week. But no promises. And in the mean time, I invite your comments and questions and discussion. I know it's not completely logical, I know not every question is answered, and surely my arguments are incomplete and flawed. I'm not a philosopher, just a girl with some thoughts. Please be nice, even if you disagree with me. I promise to love you either way.
Wednesday, November 26, 2008
thoughts on gay marriage, part 3
(Again, please bear in mind the context of this post.)
Let marriage be an institution of the church. Let civil unions be an institution of the government.
Ideologically, I think that's the viewpoint most consistent with the laws of this country, and the constitutional right to freedom of religion. It's not that easy, though. The thing about government is that while it may not legislate religion, it exists to uphold justice. And justice is itself ideological. So the morality of things gets all mixed up with the legality of things. And there's no way to really untangle those ideas.
Take, for example, adoption. Should a gay couple be allowed to adopt? Some states say yes, others say no (for a quick overview, check this out). Most studies show that gay and lesbian parents are no worse for children than heterosexual parents, overall. Surely having homosexual parents isn't a cakewalk for the kids, but it's less difficult as societal mores change and no worse than the other family issues that kids have to deal with. Is one parent better than no parent at all? Of course! Is two better than one? I think so.
So from my perspective, gay and lesbian couples can be awesome parents. The thing is, I think homosexuality is wrong in God's eyes. I think and hope that practicing homosexuals come to know God's love for them, and accept forgiveness for all of their sins, and choose to love God back, and show it by obeying what He asks them to do. And I think that ultimately this will mean ending their homosexual relationship. So what then? Just another broken home, children who were in foster care or adopted left no better off than the millions of other kids in broken families, dealing with all the crap that comes along with it.
So can I support adoption for homosexual couples? Gah. Legally it seems fine, but ethically it seems completely wrong. I have no idea what the right answer is. The thing about the separation of church and state is that no matter how hard you try to separate it, when you get down to a very personal level, there's no telling them apart. Law. Righteousness. God. Grace. Love. Family. I just don't know. (This, by the way, is why I find voting so difficult.)
A few closing thoughts, next.
Let marriage be an institution of the church. Let civil unions be an institution of the government.
Ideologically, I think that's the viewpoint most consistent with the laws of this country, and the constitutional right to freedom of religion. It's not that easy, though. The thing about government is that while it may not legislate religion, it exists to uphold justice. And justice is itself ideological. So the morality of things gets all mixed up with the legality of things. And there's no way to really untangle those ideas.
Take, for example, adoption. Should a gay couple be allowed to adopt? Some states say yes, others say no (for a quick overview, check this out). Most studies show that gay and lesbian parents are no worse for children than heterosexual parents, overall. Surely having homosexual parents isn't a cakewalk for the kids, but it's less difficult as societal mores change and no worse than the other family issues that kids have to deal with. Is one parent better than no parent at all? Of course! Is two better than one? I think so.
So from my perspective, gay and lesbian couples can be awesome parents. The thing is, I think homosexuality is wrong in God's eyes. I think and hope that practicing homosexuals come to know God's love for them, and accept forgiveness for all of their sins, and choose to love God back, and show it by obeying what He asks them to do. And I think that ultimately this will mean ending their homosexual relationship. So what then? Just another broken home, children who were in foster care or adopted left no better off than the millions of other kids in broken families, dealing with all the crap that comes along with it.
So can I support adoption for homosexual couples? Gah. Legally it seems fine, but ethically it seems completely wrong. I have no idea what the right answer is. The thing about the separation of church and state is that no matter how hard you try to separate it, when you get down to a very personal level, there's no telling them apart. Law. Righteousness. God. Grace. Love. Family. I just don't know. (This, by the way, is why I find voting so difficult.)
A few closing thoughts, next.
thoughts on gay marriage, part 2
(Again, please consider this post in the context of the previous ones.)
So far I've dealt with some of the secular issues. For many gay couples, the thing they care about is not so much legal rights as social acceptance. My earlier post about homosexuality in general addresses this issue, as does this blog post that recommends some good things to keep in mind when engaging in dialogue about homosexuality, especially as a Christian.
The thing is, this isn't the kind of acceptance that most homosexuals seem to want. They don't want a dialogue or respectful conversation about where we differ -- they want affirmation of their identity as homosexuals. Again, I've already dealt a bit with my opinions about that. But the semantics of "marriage" come into play again when we switch from what's legal to what's ideologically and socially acceptable. In the general American public, homosexuality is becoming increasingly socially normalized. But as a Christian who holds the opinions I've described, homosexuality and "marriage" can't go together.
Very traditional opening words of a protestant marriage ceremony are:
Forgive me if this seems harsh -- remember that I dearly love practicing homosexuals -- but there is no Biblical support for God's recognition of gay marriage. When the Bible speaks about homosexuality, it roundly condemns the practice. When the Bible speaks about marriage, it affirms that honorable, holy marriages are between a man and a woman. And it's not arbitrary! There are reasons that marriage is defined like it is in the Bible -- reasons literally as old as Adam. The very nature of the way our bodies are made speak to the rightness - the righteousness, if you will - of one man and one woman coming together in marriage. We were created with this in mind.
Again, please understand: I have great sympathy for those who believe they are homosexual by nature. It's not an easy thing, to have such crises of identity, to believe that you were created wrong, somehow, if this is the way God intended it. I don't have these answers, only the love of a God who wants to meet us in our deepest struggles, bind up our brokenness, fill our inner emptiness, and give us peace.
All of this is very faith-based. I believe it's completely true. And I also believe it's completely removed from the world of secular politics and government. Our country clings to the constitutional interpretation that completely separates church and state. Let it be separate, then. Don't let the government base its definitions on God's definitions, if the government is renouncing God. Let marriage be an institution of the church, one man and one woman. Let civil unions be an institution of the government, without gender restrictions.
Ideologically, I think that's the viewpoint most consistent with the laws of this country, and the constitutional right to freedom of religion. It's not that easy, though. The thing about government is that while it may not legislate religion, it exists to uphold justice. And justice is itself ideological. So the morality of things gets all mixed up with the legality of things. And there's no way to really untangle those ideas. More on this, next.
So far I've dealt with some of the secular issues. For many gay couples, the thing they care about is not so much legal rights as social acceptance. My earlier post about homosexuality in general addresses this issue, as does this blog post that recommends some good things to keep in mind when engaging in dialogue about homosexuality, especially as a Christian.
The thing is, this isn't the kind of acceptance that most homosexuals seem to want. They don't want a dialogue or respectful conversation about where we differ -- they want affirmation of their identity as homosexuals. Again, I've already dealt a bit with my opinions about that. But the semantics of "marriage" come into play again when we switch from what's legal to what's ideologically and socially acceptable. In the general American public, homosexuality is becoming increasingly socially normalized. But as a Christian who holds the opinions I've described, homosexuality and "marriage" can't go together.
Very traditional opening words of a protestant marriage ceremony are:
Dearly beloved: We have come together in the presence of God to witness and bless the joining together of this man and this woman in Holy Matrimony. The bond and covenant of marriage was established by God in creation, and our Lord Jesus Christ adorned this manner of life by his presence and first miracle at a wedding in Cana of Galilee. It signifies to us the mystery of the union between Christ and his Church, and Holy Scripture commends it to be honored among all people. The union of husband and wife in heart, body and mind is intended by God for their mutual joy; for the help and comfort given one another in property and adversity; and, when it is God's will, for the procreation of children and their nurture in the knowledge and love of the Lord. Therefore marriage is not to be entered into unadvisedly or lightly; but reverently, deliberately, and in accordance with the purposes for which it was instituted by God. (cited here, forgive my sad source, this librarian is on vacation)One of the first things you notice about this ceremony is that it's decidedly not secular. This is marriage in the presence of God. It's a covenant established in the Biblical stories of creation and Jesus' life. It's holy. It represents Christ and the church. It's for joy, comfort, help, procreation, and family. It's not for tax definitions or health insurance, or even for social acceptance.
Forgive me if this seems harsh -- remember that I dearly love practicing homosexuals -- but there is no Biblical support for God's recognition of gay marriage. When the Bible speaks about homosexuality, it roundly condemns the practice. When the Bible speaks about marriage, it affirms that honorable, holy marriages are between a man and a woman. And it's not arbitrary! There are reasons that marriage is defined like it is in the Bible -- reasons literally as old as Adam. The very nature of the way our bodies are made speak to the rightness - the righteousness, if you will - of one man and one woman coming together in marriage. We were created with this in mind.
Again, please understand: I have great sympathy for those who believe they are homosexual by nature. It's not an easy thing, to have such crises of identity, to believe that you were created wrong, somehow, if this is the way God intended it. I don't have these answers, only the love of a God who wants to meet us in our deepest struggles, bind up our brokenness, fill our inner emptiness, and give us peace.
All of this is very faith-based. I believe it's completely true. And I also believe it's completely removed from the world of secular politics and government. Our country clings to the constitutional interpretation that completely separates church and state. Let it be separate, then. Don't let the government base its definitions on God's definitions, if the government is renouncing God. Let marriage be an institution of the church, one man and one woman. Let civil unions be an institution of the government, without gender restrictions.
Ideologically, I think that's the viewpoint most consistent with the laws of this country, and the constitutional right to freedom of religion. It's not that easy, though. The thing about government is that while it may not legislate religion, it exists to uphold justice. And justice is itself ideological. So the morality of things gets all mixed up with the legality of things. And there's no way to really untangle those ideas. More on this, next.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)