As promised, some of my thoughts about gay marriage. If you haven't read my previous post wherein I share my thoughts about homosexuality in general, please do. First, some thoughts on definitions and the secular...
Recent debates in the US have centered around the "definition" of marriage. There is a federal "Defense of Marriage" law. The recent passage of Proposition 8 in California has brought the issue to the forefront again... and again, it's an issue of "defining" the term marriage.
The issue always sounds like a semantic one. Is "marriage" a commitment between any couple, or only a heterosexual couple? Certainly the semantics are important. The word "marriage" has a tremendous amount of baggage attached to it. When we hear the word, we think of the relationship between our parents. We think of a ceremony with a bride and groom. We think of special intimacy. We think of life together, through good times and bad. We think of tax implications (well, some people do). We think of marriage in the way it has been modeled around us, and that is different for everyone.
So I'd like to propose that we pause for a moment and consider not the definition of marriage, but the implications of marriage. (The effectual semantics.) In today's culture, any two people can have a relationship that mimics traditional marriage. Life together does not require a marriage certificate. Sex certainly doesn't. And all kinds of people raise children together (or apart). Call it what you will, in terms of practical lifestyle, marriage-like relationships are all over the place.
So why does it matter how marriage is defined?
A major issue is that marriage has significant financial repercussions. Married people (may) have different tax burdens than single people. And while any people can live together and share the burden of living expenses, health care is extremely expensive. It is an employer's insurance plan that dictates whether or not "domestic partners" -- people living together -- can be insured under each other's health insurance policy. (Interestingly, the policies vary by employer, not by health care company. Also, no one seems to be asking about relationships between more than two people. Yet.)
So from one perspective, the way the government and businesses define marriage is important because of these financial issues. Personally, this is where I think it is very easy to draw a sacred/secular line. When we're talking about taxes and health care costs, we're talking about secular stuff, not sacred stuff. This is where equal rights comes into play. While there's no equal rights amendment in the US Constitution, establishing justice is the second purpose statement of the constitution. Given this mission statement, I think that one couple should be treated the same as any other couple. Remember, their lifestyles are virtually indistinguishable from those of "married" couples. So I think that tax burdens and insurance requirements should be the same for any kind of couple, if there must be a distinction between couples and single people. (And there are good reasons to make that distinction. Ask me about it if you disagree.)
Of course, marriage has typically been the standard for deciding at what point a relationship is "official" enough to be recognized by businesses and the government. Without some kind of standard, any two people could decide to claim the official benefits/liabilities of couple-ness. So far, the idea of "civil union" has been the standard for distinguishing between random couples and "official" couples. It basically establishes the rights of kinship without a shared bloodline, just like marriage does otherwise. (A quick search shows that in NJ a civil union has age and same-gender requirements, as well as an "only-one-at-a-time" kind of rule). Wikipedia calls it a theoretical legal mechanism, and I think that's really all it is. A secular mechanism for determining legal status of couples. A mechanism for ensuring secular justice.
So far I've dealt with some of the secular issues. For many gay couples, the thing they care about is not so much legal rights as social and ideological acceptance. More on that next.
Wednesday, November 26, 2008
Wednesday, November 19, 2008
Homosexuality and Christianity
This post is in response to the article that Dan posted here, which refers to this article. I'll post my thoughts about gay marriage later. Here are my basic thoughts about homosexuality.
People often ask me my views of gay marriage, and I think it's my responsibility to consider the issue and have a well-thought-out answer. As the Christ-following daughter of a lesbian couple who have been together for fourteen years, I am in the unique position of having both firm moral convictions (that I believe are Biblical) and also having a vested interest in the way homosexuals are treated in the church and in the world.
First, I should say that I believe homosexual practice is unequivocally condemned by the Bible. There are scads of verses that support this stance, and if you'd like to hear more about this let me know and we'll discuss it.
Second, I firmly believe that all people, homosexuals included, are unequivocally loved by God with a fierce, passionate, deep, and righteous love. I cannot describe this love: just thinking about it makes my heart ache and sets tears of joy, thanksgiving, and sorrow flowing. It's the kind of love that you can't look at for too long, because it cuts deep and does not leave the beloved one unchanged. I firmly believe that a person who has deep feelings of love for another person of the same sex is beloved by God and should be treated as such by all the world, especially Christians.
I also believe that it is possible for a homosexual to be a redeemed, Christ-following Christian. The feelings of a person's heart toward another person of the same sex is not an insurmountable obstacle through which the grace of God cannot penetrate. Homosexuals can be Christians. But let me qualify that. If homosexuality is a sin, and it is, then a Christ-following homosexual will, at one point or other, be convicted that their lifestyle is outside the 'narrow road' that God would have them walk. Most of the time I'm pretty sure that conviction comes early on in a person's walk with God, because growth in Christ is seriously limited by the sinful patterns in our life. A homosexual who comes to Christ will have to end the active homosexual pattern of behavior in his or her life in order to walk with Christ, just as a person in a heterosexual relationship would have to end the sinful parts of their heterosexual relationship in order to grow in Christ.
I'm not insensitive, though. I'm not saying it's easy. Our culture says and many people firmly believe that their identity, the way that they were created, is to love people of the same gender. I cannot speak to the way people were created, though I believe God is both sovereign and loving as creator AND has forbidden homosexual behavior. I am good friends with people who live in the agony of feeling like they were created wrong, who hate that they cannot have the desires of their hearts fulfilled and also live according to God's revealed will. I understand why some Christ-followers choose to practice homosexuality, though as I said I think this will prevent their growth in Christ and likely facilitate their falling away from him. (Ultimately when it comes to sin there are powers of light and powers of darkness, and if we do not choose to claim the victory over sin by God's grace, the darkness gets a foothold and can reassert authority in our lives. And this goes for any pattern of sin, not just homosexuality) I think the best answer for Christ-following homosexuals is to practice abstinence. It can be excruciatingly difficult in a million ways, but I believe our God is greater than even the deep-seated things of the heart. Where it is His will, there is a way.
Again, let me just express my deepest love for both homosexuals and heterosexuals. This is a really hard topic, and it deserves to be discussed with care and respect. There's nothing I despise more than the ungrace shown by so many Christians toward homosexuals. It breaks my heart.
If you'd like to discuss this further, I'm certainly happy to oblige. Again, I have a vested interest on both sides, and I also have some unique experience dealing with both personal and institutional questions of sexuality, and also with the consequences of sexual sin and brokenness (my own and other people's). So let's talk about it. With love and respect.
Next up, a more direct response to the question of gay marriage.
People often ask me my views of gay marriage, and I think it's my responsibility to consider the issue and have a well-thought-out answer. As the Christ-following daughter of a lesbian couple who have been together for fourteen years, I am in the unique position of having both firm moral convictions (that I believe are Biblical) and also having a vested interest in the way homosexuals are treated in the church and in the world.
First, I should say that I believe homosexual practice is unequivocally condemned by the Bible. There are scads of verses that support this stance, and if you'd like to hear more about this let me know and we'll discuss it.
Second, I firmly believe that all people, homosexuals included, are unequivocally loved by God with a fierce, passionate, deep, and righteous love. I cannot describe this love: just thinking about it makes my heart ache and sets tears of joy, thanksgiving, and sorrow flowing. It's the kind of love that you can't look at for too long, because it cuts deep and does not leave the beloved one unchanged. I firmly believe that a person who has deep feelings of love for another person of the same sex is beloved by God and should be treated as such by all the world, especially Christians.
I also believe that it is possible for a homosexual to be a redeemed, Christ-following Christian. The feelings of a person's heart toward another person of the same sex is not an insurmountable obstacle through which the grace of God cannot penetrate. Homosexuals can be Christians. But let me qualify that. If homosexuality is a sin, and it is, then a Christ-following homosexual will, at one point or other, be convicted that their lifestyle is outside the 'narrow road' that God would have them walk. Most of the time I'm pretty sure that conviction comes early on in a person's walk with God, because growth in Christ is seriously limited by the sinful patterns in our life. A homosexual who comes to Christ will have to end the active homosexual pattern of behavior in his or her life in order to walk with Christ, just as a person in a heterosexual relationship would have to end the sinful parts of their heterosexual relationship in order to grow in Christ.
I'm not insensitive, though. I'm not saying it's easy. Our culture says and many people firmly believe that their identity, the way that they were created, is to love people of the same gender. I cannot speak to the way people were created, though I believe God is both sovereign and loving as creator AND has forbidden homosexual behavior. I am good friends with people who live in the agony of feeling like they were created wrong, who hate that they cannot have the desires of their hearts fulfilled and also live according to God's revealed will. I understand why some Christ-followers choose to practice homosexuality, though as I said I think this will prevent their growth in Christ and likely facilitate their falling away from him. (Ultimately when it comes to sin there are powers of light and powers of darkness, and if we do not choose to claim the victory over sin by God's grace, the darkness gets a foothold and can reassert authority in our lives. And this goes for any pattern of sin, not just homosexuality) I think the best answer for Christ-following homosexuals is to practice abstinence. It can be excruciatingly difficult in a million ways, but I believe our God is greater than even the deep-seated things of the heart. Where it is His will, there is a way.
Again, let me just express my deepest love for both homosexuals and heterosexuals. This is a really hard topic, and it deserves to be discussed with care and respect. There's nothing I despise more than the ungrace shown by so many Christians toward homosexuals. It breaks my heart.
If you'd like to discuss this further, I'm certainly happy to oblige. Again, I have a vested interest on both sides, and I also have some unique experience dealing with both personal and institutional questions of sexuality, and also with the consequences of sexual sin and brokenness (my own and other people's). So let's talk about it. With love and respect.
Next up, a more direct response to the question of gay marriage.
Friday, November 7, 2008
he and i
It's been an amazing few weeks for seeing the beauty and creativity and love of God everywhere. I wanted to share this passage from He and I, a book of prayers of Gabrielle Bossis, a French woman who lived from 1874-1950. The cool thing about this book is that it's a record not so much of Gabrielle's prayers, but of God's responses to her. This excerpt is from October 4, 1948.
Today you will contemplate My beauty. Already this morning you saw that deep flush of color arrowing the eastern horizon, and as you passed under the trees you stopped to admire the long October spider webs festooned from branch to branch and spangled with drops of dew like rows of pearls in open necklaces. Then as the sun rose, the crickets that had been vocal all night long in your cherry tree suddenly ceased their singing; the Loire mirrored one hue after another in a rich medley of unearthly colors. And the herons passed over, streaking the violet sky.
If you have eyes to see, every hour of the day holds its splendor. It comes from Me, from a fragment of Me. For you, of course -- so that you may learn the lure of praise, the joy of adoration, the love of Love. And I vary my spectacles every morning to rejuvenate your hearts.
Have you anyone else so ingenious in his ways of pleasing you? You have someone to carve the clouds into the shapes you love, haven't you? And an engineer to swell the tide so that the water reaches the wall of your terrace? What tradesman placed the birds in your trees and so many butterflies around your flowers? And this morning, was it a dealter in tulle who unfolded that chiffon scarf of mist right across your island, turning it into to storeys?
Whose hand plucks the yellow leaves of your linden trees with such grace while your strawberry plants offer you their long rest for the fruit of future years?
Open your eyes wide and look at Love. It is He who is passing by.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)